28
edits
Difference between revisions of "Iowa City West NW"
no edit summary
| Line 20: | Line 20: | ||
Libertarianism Framework: [[File:Libertarianism Framework.docx]] | Libertarianism Framework: [[File:Libertarianism Framework.docx]] | ||
Libertarianism AC | January-February 2023 Libertarianism AC: [[File:JF2023 Libertarianism AC.docx]] | ||
'''Ripstein''': Ripstein is similar to Libertarianism or Kant but more robust and more selective in terms of what is a "right". Ripstein just says you have the right to be independent (as opposed to a right to absolute freedom) which means you must be allowed to make your own choices but the government can do things like tax you. If you're interested in this framework I would recommend reading the book Force and Freedom by Arthur Ripstein, it goes in depth on a lot of issues relevant to a framework debate and is a pretty easy read. | '''Ripstein''': Ripstein is similar to Libertarianism or Kant but more robust and more selective in terms of what is a "right". Ripstein just says you have the right to be independent (as opposed to a right to absolute freedom) which means you must be allowed to make your own choices but the government can do things like tax you. If you're interested in this framework I would recommend reading the book Force and Freedom by Arthur Ripstein, it goes in depth on a lot of issues relevant to a framework debate and is a pretty easy read. | ||
| Line 28: | Line 28: | ||
[[:File:Ripstein Framework.docx|File:Ripstein Framework.docx]] | [[:File:Ripstein Framework.docx|File:Ripstein Framework.docx]] | ||
Ripstein AC: | September-October 2022 Ripstein AC: | ||
[[:File:SO2023 Ripstein AC.docx|File:SO2023 Ripstein AC.docx]] | [[:File:SO2023 Ripstein AC.docx|File:SO2023 Ripstein AC.docx]] | ||
Ripstein NC: | January-February 2023 Ripstein NC: | ||
[[:File:JF2023 Ripstein NC.docx|File:JF2023 Ripstein NC.docx]] | [[:File:JF2023 Ripstein NC.docx|File:JF2023 Ripstein NC.docx]] | ||
'''Polls''': This framework says the moral thing to do is just what the most people thing is the right thing to do (which we determine via public opinion polls). The meta-ethic of moral relativism is kind of interesting and strategic against a lot of other frameworks but is fairly difficult to defend. | |||
November-December 2022 Polls AC: | |||
[[:File:ND2022 Polls AC.docx|File:ND2022 Polls AC.docx]] | |||