Content-Manager, Administrators
203
edits
Difference between revisions of "Prospect ST (Sophia Tian)"
→Docs
CheeseMeese (talk | contribs) (→Docs) |
CheeseMeese (talk | contribs) (→Docs) |
||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
I did a lot of phil debate in my career since it was the easiest option available to me at the time (didn't require much prep). It also didn't require as much coaching, so I find it a valuable option for people (mostly in Texas/the East Coast) who don't want to spend that much money on this activity. | I did a lot of phil debate in my career since it was the easiest option available to me at the time (didn't require much prep). It also didn't require as much coaching, so I find it a valuable option for people (mostly in Texas/the East Coast) who don't want to spend that much money on this activity. | ||
I get some questions asking me how I did phil debate as a small school, so I thought I'd answer them here. I'm also a bit sad phil is dying in LD, so all my cases and frontlines (with some explanations) are below. | I get some questions asking me how I did phil debate as a small school, so I thought I'd answer them here. I'm also a bit sad phil is dying in LD, so all my cases and frontlines (with some explanations) are below. | ||
Feel free to [[User:CheeseMeese|contact me]] with any questions! | Feel free to [[User:CheeseMeese|contact me]] with any questions! | ||
| Line 23: | Line 23: | ||
== Docs == | == Docs == | ||
Here are all the positions I read -- I mostly included things I cut myself with topic-specific frontlines. Any policy position I read was likely cut by Elmer Yang or stolen off the wiki. I rarely actually used prewritten frontlines -- writing them was just so I could think about them through and articulate my thoughts. | Here are all the positions I read -- I mostly included things I cut myself with topic-specific frontlines. Any policy position I read was likely cut by Elmer Yang or stolen off the wiki. I rarely actually used prewritten frontlines -- writing them was just so I could think about them through and articulate my thoughts. | ||
[https://opencaselist.com/hsld22/Prospect/SoTi HSLD 2022--2023] | |||
[https://opencaselist.com/hsld21/Prospect/SoTi HSLD 2021--2022] | |||
=== 2022 -- 2023 === | === 2022 -- 2023 === | ||
==== January/February ==== | ==== January/February ==== | ||
| Line 87: | Line 91: | ||
[[:File:Prospect ST -- SO22 Telesurgery PIC.docx|SO22 -- Telesurgery PIC]] | [[:File:Prospect ST -- SO22 Telesurgery PIC.docx|SO22 -- Telesurgery PIC]] | ||
This was pretty straightforward -- it was again super libertarian in saying that distribution is unjustified since people have a right to their property and followed Nozick's Wilt Chamberlain example of "poverty is a choice." Sigh. | This was pretty straightforward -- it was again super libertarian in saying that distribution is unjustified since people have a right to their property and followed Nozick's Wilt Chamberlain example of "poverty is a choice." Sigh. | ||
[[:File:Prospect ST -- SO22 Kant NC.docx|SO22 -- Kant NC]] | [[:File:Prospect ST -- SO22 Kant NC.docx|SO22 -- Kant NC]] | ||
| Line 118: | Line 122: | ||
[[:File:Prospect ST -- ND21 Kant AC Frontlines.docx|ND21 -- Kant AC Frontlines]] | [[:File:Prospect ST -- ND21 Kant AC Frontlines.docx|ND21 -- Kant AC Frontlines]] | ||
===== NCs ===== | ===== NCs ===== | ||
Cut this one at camp and docbotted all of my 2NRs on it :') | Cut this one at camp and docbotted all of my 2NRs on it :') | ||
| Line 129: | Line 132: | ||
[[:File:Prospect ST -- ND21 Particularism NC.docx|ND21 -- Particularism NC]] | [[:File:Prospect ST -- ND21 Particularism NC.docx|ND21 -- Particularism NC]] | ||
==== September/October ==== | ==== September/October ==== | ||
===== ACs ===== | ===== ACs ===== | ||